patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

I Pledge Allegiance to My Health … and the Treatments That Work For Me

Open your mind to new possibilities

 

Want to know a secret?

Despite my belief in and praise for alternative therapies, I, too, wonder if they work and are worth the money.

I wonder if the yoga mantras and deep breathing are enough to eliminate the high amount of stress I feel right now.

I wonder if the $200 I just charged to my AmEx for "therapeutic grade supplements" will translate into hormone balance and decreased risk of cancer.

I wonder if I should regret the time I spent visiting my chiropractor three times a week in the hopes of having a natural birth after a Cesarean. (Considering I ended up with a C-section any way...)

I wonder, like my brother (who posed the question over Thanksgiving dinner), should I even spend time concerning myself over diet and lifestyle when we "all die anyway?"

And sometimes I feel like a fraud and a fake for writing about therapies of which I don't have any more than anecdotal proof that they work.

And sometimes I am shamed into silence by the friend who tells me a modality didn't work for her.

And sometimes I have to tell a community member or a colleague that a particular therapy didn't work for me.

Does this mean that alternative medicine is bogus?

100 percent NOT.

I am one person. One mother. One community member. One investigator. One person on "the path" with a medical history and an opinion.

I am fortunate to have discovered alternative therapies that made a difference for my family. I feel grateful that I have the platform on which to share this with you. But it doesn't mean that I don't continue to question and to explore and to challenge.

You should, too.

Just as you should walk into a doctor's office with a list of questions and the determination to wait around until your questions are all answered, you should bring with you the confidence to ask a holistic health practitioner for an explanation on how the modality works and referrals from patients who have seen success.

Just as you wouldn't write off the entire medical profession after an appointment with one bad egg, you shouldn't snub your nose at alternative medicine as a whole just because you've been told it's all quackery and voodoo.

Just as you would fill a prescription and shell out a co-pay for a medication you've never heard of but is supposed to relieve your pain, I invite you to consider taking a chance and spending money on an alternative therapy that might make as much of a difference, if not more, than that pill you've just popped.

Neither conventional medicine, nor alternative, requires your 100 percent commitment or allegiance. Trust me, I know.

I've learned to count on, and be grateful for, both.

But I've also learned that scientific study is not the only indicator for whether or not a treatment will work. And I've discovered the true value of a glowing testimonial.

I've opened my mind to possibilities for wellness I formerly thought implausible.

And the only way I could have done this was to respectfully listen to my doubts … and to choose anyway.

About this column: Jen Maidenberg is the founder of Mindful Living NJ and also is trying to consciously raise three healthy kids without driving herself insane.

Judie Hurtado

9:44 am on Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Jen, thank you for writing this insightful piece. I, too, am constantly exploring alternative modalities. I love writing, researching and sharing my experiences with the community. Sometimes they "work" and sometimes they don't but I usually enjoy the journey. Thank you for putting yourself out there.

Reply

Dr. Michael Magwood

2:41 pm on Tuesday, November 30, 2010

The research is out there for all those to investigate. Jen is right. A nice blend of scientific investigation, case studies and anecdote is enough to build confidence in most people. I subscribe to a monthly review that summarizes dozens of chiropractic and medical journals. So when someone says, "The science doesn't exist," I just show them where to find it. Then the bias becomes clear. BTW, who money double blind control group studies exist in support of open heart surgery? We just tend to know that it tends to serve it's purpose.

Reply

Bronwyn

11:44 am on Wednesday, January 12, 2011

"Just as you would fill a prescription and shell out a co-pay for a medication you've never heard of but is supposed to relieve your pain, I invite you to consider taking a chance and spending money on an alternative therapy that might make as much of a difference, if not more, than that pill you've just popped."

The medication somebody has never heard of has undergone extensive study--Phase I, II, III trials--where the safety and efficacy are tested on thousands of people; it is not a sign of gullibility to pop that pill whose chemical name is barely pronounceable. It's actually a sign of logic and a trust in medicine that has served society well. Now, popping a homeopathic pill that contains as much "medicine" as would be found by dropping a single drop of some substance in all the oceans of the world is a sign of not using critical thinking.

People should require convincing evidence before they ingest some medicine or undergo a procedure. They understandably trust that the evidence is there for much of mainstream medicine. It's not perfect and mistakes are made but it's pretty good. Chiropractic does not stand up to the test of clinical trials and it should. A testimonial is not good evidence because there are a million other reasons that the treatment worked.

It's condescending to insinuate the people who do not buy into magnet therapy, homeopathy, etc are close-minded. It's the exact opposite in fact. It's all about evidence. (But, I am all for meditation.)

Reply

Right of Center

12:29 pm on Wednesday, January 12, 2011

it's incredibly irresponsible to recommend treatments based on anecdotal "evidence", no matter how well meaning you are. Your advice might cause someone harm because they choose an ineffective treatment.

Reply

Leave a comment