Top 5 Montclair Restaurants Reviewed on Yelp!

Agree or disagree with the citizen-driven restaurant ratings on Yelp!?

Websites like Yelp! have empowered the everyday eater to become their local neighborhood's New York Times food critic, praising and damning behind the anonymity of a computer screen.

Some peeved restaurateurs have argued Yelp! is little more than a "forum for the uninformed," a digitally-savvy clan of unsophisticated palates with little-to-no culinary education.

True or not, the reviews listed on the website unquestionably impact popular perception. Will you dine at a place one newspaper critic gave a dazzling review to if the same restaurant was scorned by the unwashed masses? Maybe. Maybe not.

So how does the average joe review the many restaurants in Montclair?

Based on Yelp!'s number of reviews, we countdown from #5 down to #1 the most reviewed restaurants in Montclair. 

5. Ah'Pizz, 4 Stars, 114 Reviews

"This place is amazing," said Toni D of Montclair. "Make sure you have reservations on the weekend.  I am a pizza purist and always order the margarita pie.  For dessert don't forget to ask about the Nutella pizza.  You will not be the same after eating it."

4. Toast, 3.5 Stars, 132 Reviews

"All this review really needs is 3 words:  RED.  VELVET.  PANCAKES." said mackenzie a. of Verona.

3: Mesob Ethiopian Restaurant, 4 Stars, 183 Reviews

"Love this place!," said Lisa C. of Montclair. "The food is fantastic, I could eat it everyday.  My husband and I share the vegetarian meal and there is not a scrap left when we are done. The owner is wonderful as well, she remembers you and always makes you feel welcome.  A loyal customer in us!"

2: Raymond's, 4 Stars, 240 Reviews

"Raymond's holds a special place in my heart as I have had so many memorable meals here with some of the most important people of my life," said Amos D. of Montclair. 

" ...For me, Raymonds embodies what it is to be a Montclairion. Great atmosphere, inside/outside eating in the summer, long lines :( and quality food and preparation."

1. Cuban Pete's, 4 Stars, 364 Reviews

"Great atmosphere," said Chris C. of Lyndhurst. "Amazing food. The appetizers are amazing. Chorizo is phenomenal and they give so much. BYOB is a good thing. Usually crowded, but tons of fun."


What do you think of the Yelp! top 5 list? 

chris February 21, 2013 at 06:39 PM
Where's Giotto and Finn?? AND Halcyon for that matter!
joyce hahnebach February 21, 2013 at 08:40 PM
Giotto,finn,halcyon,bistro 18and now 12 WEst-try getting into any of these restaurants on a friday and saturday-jammed packed! The patrons should be reviewing NOT yelp!
john clue February 21, 2013 at 10:19 PM
This really doesn't reflect the quality of places in Montclair if Cuban Pete's rates number 1. Are you kidding me? that should be on the other end as opposed to the upper end. Most of you are correct about Giotto, Finn, Halcyon and many others. What a shame this came out but then I guess we know the true is different. Cuban Pete's??? Wow that is desperation.
Dbc February 27, 2013 at 02:54 PM
I love the "forum for the uninformed" quote...I agree with above comments about all of the great Montclair restos omitted from the list. For the most part, these reviews reflect more about the owners' media savvy than their culinary skills, for sure! Again, Cuban Pete's???


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »